How ClickUp Teams Can Choose the Right AI Model

ClickUp users are increasingly experimenting with AI to summarize content, draft documents, analyze data, and speed up daily work. But with so many models on the market, it can be difficult to know which AI system will give your team the most reliable, cost-effective results.

This how-to guide walks you through a practical, step-by-step process for comparing AI models using the same reasoning framework that underlies DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT evaluations. You will learn how to define your needs, run structured tests, and interpret results so you can confidently select the best AI model to power your workflows.

Step 1: Clarify Your ClickUp AI Use Cases

Before you compare tools, define where AI will have the most impact in your workspace. Clear use cases make testing faster and more objective.

Identify your core workflows in ClickUp

List the recurring tasks where AI could realistically save time or improve quality, such as:

• Summarizing meeting notes and long documents
• Drafting task descriptions, comments, and status updates
• Creating SOPs, checklists, and project briefs
• Brainstorming ideas for campaigns or product features
• Transforming raw data into actionable insights

For each workflow, write a one-sentence goal. For example, “Generate a concise summary of a 2,000-word project update with clear next steps.” These goals will later become prompt templates for your AI tests.

Map AI to roles and teams

Different teams working in ClickUp will need different strengths from an AI model. Product managers may prioritize structured documentation, while marketing teams care more about tone and creativity.

Document which departments will use AI and what success means for each group. This will help you choose evaluation criteria that reflect real-world expectations.

Step 2: Build a Repeatable Prompt Set

An effective AI comparison depends on consistent prompts. Use your earlier workflow definitions to create a prompt library that you can reuse across models like DeepSeek and ChatGPT.

Create task-specific prompt templates

Turn each workflow into a structured prompt. For example:

• Summarization prompt: “Summarize the following update in 5 bullet points with clear action items and owners.”
• Documentation prompt: “Draft a step-by-step SOP for the process described below, using headings and numbered steps.”
• Brainstorming prompt: “Generate 10 campaign ideas targeted at [audience], each with a short description and success metric.”

Keep formatting, length, and instructions consistent so each AI system is tested under identical conditions.

Include both simple and complex prompts

To fully evaluate AI behavior, design prompts that cover:

• Short, direct instructions
• Long, multi-part instructions
• Requests that require reasoning or math
• Content that must respect a specific tone or style

This mix reveals how each model handles basic tasks compared to nuanced reasoning.

Step 3: Set Evaluation Criteria Before Testing

Objective criteria are essential for a fair comparison of models like DeepSeek and ChatGPT. Define them before you look at any results.

Core quality criteria for ClickUp workflows

Use the same quality lenses across all your tests:

• Accuracy: Are facts, calculations, and interpretations correct?
• Relevance: Does the answer stay focused on the task and context?
• Clarity: Is the writing easy to understand and well-structured?
• Actionability: Does the output clearly suggest next steps or decisions?
• Consistency: Does the model behave similarly on repeated prompts?

Assign a simple 1–5 score for each criterion per response, then average scores for each model.

Operational criteria for ongoing use

Beyond quality, consider how each AI will affect daily operations in ClickUp:

• Speed: How quickly does it respond under typical load?
• Cost: What is the estimated monthly spend at your expected usage level?
• Control: Can you apply custom instructions that align with your processes?
• Safety: How well does it avoid harmful or off-brand content?

Document these factors so stakeholders can weigh trade-offs between price, performance, and reliability.

Step 4: Run Side-by-Side Tests

With prompts and criteria ready, you can now test multiple AI models in a structured way, drawing on the comparison patterns shown in the DeepSeek AI vs. ChatGPT analysis in the source breakdown.

How to run controlled tests

1. Choose 5–10 prompts from your library that represent your most important workflows.
2. Send the exact same prompt to each AI model without modifications.
3. Copy the outputs into a neutral document and remove model names to avoid bias.
4. Score each answer using your predefined quality and operational criteria.
5. Average scores per prompt and per model to identify patterns.

Keep the environment as similar as possible when you run these tests so you are truly comparing model capabilities rather than external variables.

Use multiple reviewers

Invite reviewers from different teams who actually work in ClickUp every day. Have each reviewer score responses independently, then compare ratings to see where opinions align or diverge. This surfaces strengths or weaknesses that only appear in real-world usage.

Step 5: Interpret Results for ClickUp Workflows

After you collect scores and feedback, you need to translate test data into practical decisions that will affect how your workspace uses AI.

Identify model strengths and weaknesses

Look for these patterns in your test results:

• Models that excel in summarization but struggle with detailed planning
• Models that are highly creative but occasionally less precise
• Models that produce very consistent, predictable outputs

Match each pattern to specific workflows. For instance, a model strong in accuracy and structure is a better candidate for SOPs and technical documentation created alongside your tasks and Docs.

Decide on a primary and backup model

In many cases, teams benefit from selecting one primary AI model and at least one backup. The primary model handles most ClickUp use cases, while the backup can be used when you need a different style, deeper reasoning, or alternative perspective.

Base this decision on:

• Average quality scores across your top workflows
• Cost and speed at your forecasted usage
• Feedback from reviewers performing their real roles

Step 6: Design Prompts That Scale in ClickUp

Even the best AI system needs strong prompts to be effective. Use your testing experience to refine prompts and make them reusable across your workspace.

Standardize prompt patterns

Capture the prompts that produced the best results in your tests and turn them into templates, such as:

• “Summarize this task thread in 5 bullets, including decisions, owners, and deadlines.”
• “Convert this meeting note into a project plan with milestones, risks, and next steps.”
• “Rewrite this update in a concise, executive-ready format.”

Standardization makes it easier for everyone in ClickUp to get dependable outcomes, regardless of their prompt-writing experience.

Refine tone and structure guidelines

Use clear instructions for tone, format, and audience, like “professional but friendly,” “bulleted list,” or “C-level summary.” Over time, adjust these guidelines based on feedback from your stakeholders and clients so AI outputs consistently match your brand voice.

Step 7: Monitor AI Performance Over Time

AI models evolve quickly, and your internal processes will evolve too. Build a lightweight review cycle to ensure the model you chose continues to be the best fit for your ClickUp workflows.

Collect ongoing feedback

Add a simple feedback loop to your workspace, for example:

• A quick rating scale on AI-generated outputs
• A recurring task or doc where users report issues and successes
• Periodic review meetings to check whether AI is actually saving time

Use this feedback to adjust prompts, update training resources, and—when needed—retest alternative models.

Schedule periodic re-evaluations

Because new models and updates arrive frequently, plan regular comparison cycles using the same framework you used for your original tests. Revisit the DeepSeek AI vs. ChatGPT style of evaluation to confirm your current setup is still the best option for your use cases.

Next Steps and Additional Resources

By clearly defining your workflows, designing structured prompts, and running side-by-side evaluations, you can confidently select and maintain an AI model strategy that supports your ClickUp workspace.

If you need help designing a scalable AI evaluation or implementation plan, you can explore consulting resources from Consultevo for broader workflow optimization and integration support.

To see a detailed example of how two leading models compare in real scenarios, review the full DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT breakdown available at the original source page. Use the principles in this how-to guide together with that analysis to build an AI strategy tailored to your team’s needs.

Need Help With ClickUp?

If you want expert help building, automating, or scaling your ClickUp workspace, work with ConsultEvo — trusted ClickUp Solution Partners.

Get Help

“`